More importantly, do your schools do "8th Grade Graduation"?
If you do, I'm sorry. You'll probably think I'm a nut. But I don't get it.
My son did a K-6 grade school, and they did a "6th Grade Celebration", telling us they couldn't use the word "graduation". However the cake they supplied at the Celebration had graduation caps on it. *eyeroll* It made no difference to me, really. I just found it ironic.
He attended a middle school, consisting of 7th and 8th grade. Two years. They were lucky to be acknowledged as they were kicked out the door, let alone have a celebration or "graduation".
But since that time, I've heard the subject come up more and more. Lela's son had an 8th Grade Graduation, but she refused to call it that and called it a "Promotion". (See why we are such good friends?)
So I'm wondering, what exactly are you graduating from in 8th grade? No, I get it, they are moving onto high school, a big step in the world. I get it. But to graduate sort of implies your done with something. To graduate from 8th grade is kind of a cruel joke. Dude, you have FOUR more years just to get through your basic, required education! And it isn't all cheerleaders and football players. It's freaking projects and reports that take hours, teachers who are lazy and let other students grade your work, finals that make you sweat, and pressure to choose a college and a career before you've even decided what to wear to school tomorrow.
I also get that when you've gone to a K-8 private school, you are leaving a group of kids that you've essentially known your whole school-life. Most of them will go to different high schools and move on. I get that, too. You could say you are "graduating" from that time in your life, I suppose. And I'm sure as a parent, I'd get sucked into the
But it seems like things for our kids are sometimes getting puffed up so much, I wonder if they know what real accomplishment is. Everyone on the team gets a trophy. We "graduate" from 8th grade
My nieces "graduated" from their K-8 private Christian school, and for each one, it required, not one, not two, but THREE fancy dresses. Because they are directly attached to their church, there was first some sort of Church ceremony that required a fancy dress. Which was covered by white gown for the whole thing. Then there was the Big Banquet. It is a dinner, award presentations and dance for students and parents only. (You know, girls dance the prerequisite dance with Dad, boys with Mom, then the kids all dance in a big group.) For this, there was a formal gown. Like one would wear to a prom.
Maybe my neck of the woods is just low key. Or maybe I'm a grinch. High school graduation is a big deal around here. And I like it that way.
***Ally the Grinch
Tweet

8 comments:
In my day, there was no middle school. Elementary school was K-6th, and 7-12 was a combination Jr/Sr high school.
That slowly changed, but even my two oldest went to a Jr/Sr high school. By the time my youngest came up though, they had middle school, but there were no such things as graduation until the end of 12th grade.
Having graduations for every level reminds me of how they reward kids in sports. Everyone gets a trophy just for being on a team, even if it's last place. Call me old school, but we do not need to formally congratulate kids for leaving elementary or middle school.
Call me 'old school' (cause I can take it) but I feel like all those extra graduation ceremonies (and expenses) kinda take something away from the wonder and spectacle that is high school graduation (and college for that matter). My younger son had a kindergarten graduation, an 8th grade graduation, then high school, then college, then law school. I.AM.BROKE.
I hear you loud and clear. I remember when I graduated from kindergarten and then not another one until I got out of high school. Here they graduate from elementary, from junior high and then high school. They evn have yearbooks in elementary school. Seriously?? just give me the class picture and move on with it would you.. OH and let's not forget now they have JUNIOR high class rings, and yearbooks as well for them. Umm not.. You get the class ring from high school only and MAYBE the yearbook your junior and senior years..
I don't think this makes you a grinch. :)
I had a niece finish 8th grade last year. There was a promotion ceremony or something (they were sure not to call it graduation), and she was one of the speakers. We were all so proud of her! She didn't really want any family to come, but we all did anyway. Hehe. There was no expectation of gifts or anything.
This year, I had a niece finish 8th grade on my husband's side. She lives far away from us, but we got an announcement in the mail. In it, it said something like in lieu of gifts, feel free to send money to help her be able to go to basketball camp this summer. I was a little shocked at that.
I guess I could really go either way on this issue. I do see some merit to it, but at the same time, I do see your point about it being a little like giving trophies to everyone.
I do remember thinking how ridiculous kindergarten graduation was. I don't recall 8th graduation/promotion/celebration/whatever when I was younger. Oh, yeah, that's because I went to K-6 elementary, 7-9 Jr High, and 10-12 Sr High.
Sorry for the lengthy comment. Probably could've been a post by itself. *shrug*
In Canada we only have K-8, so our celebration was graduating from grade school. We had a mass then pizza dinner including a dance. Nothing big. But now a days? It's like prom. I don't get it.
OMG I couldn't agree with you two more! I once made fun of my friend when her daughter was spending a small fortune on dress, shoes, hair cut, manicure, for a grade 8 "graduation"...suffice it to say, I may have been a bit ruthless on the topic. We are no longer friends.
I could totally hang out with you guys and we could make fun of the other mothers together!
Hey there, Grinchy, I wholeheartedly agree with you. It's kind of like a pre-engagement ring--a lotta hype about nothing.
Thank you for saying this. I find it so ridiculous that we feel every transition deserves a monumental celebration.
The 8th grade graduations at my kids' school were like a mini-prom!
Post a Comment